Science Teacher Ki Online Tutoring Income: Vedantu Vs Direct Students

Mere phone mein abhi bhi woh screenshot hai. February 2025, mahine ki earning: ₹7,240. Uske theek neeche ek aur screenshot hai, is saal March ka: ₹18,730.

Dono mahine maine almost same hours padhaya tha. Farq sirf itna tha ki pehla wala ek badi edtech platform se aaya tha aur doosra mere apne direct students se.

Main ek government-aided school mein science padhata hoon, Class 9 aur 10. Chemistry meri main line hai par is level pe Physics, Bio sab padhana padta hai. Online tutoring maine 2024 ke end mein shuru ki thi kyunki school ki salary se mahine ka hisaab tight chal raha tha. Aur jo do saal mein seekha, woh yahan pura likh raha hoon. Platform wala side bhi, direct wala side bhi.

---

Platform pe kaise ghusa

Sach batao toh Vedantu mera pehla choice nahi tha. Maine teen jagah apply kiya tha ek hi hafte mein. Ek se kabhi reply nahi aaya. Doosre ne demo ke baad reject kar diya, unhone bola meri "screen presence" weak hai. Us din bura laga tha, ab samajh aata hai ki galat nahi bole the.

Teesri jagah select ho gaya. Part-time tutor, Class 9-10 science, shaam ke slots.

Onboarding mein unhone jo training di, woh honestly kaafi useful thi. Digital whiteboard pe likhna, students ko har 4-5 minute mein engage karna, camera angle. Ye cheezein mujhe khud kabhi samajh nahi aati. School mein 16 saal padhane ke baad bhi online padhana alag skill nikli. Isko maanna pada.

Pehla payout aaya ₹3,860 ka, aadhe mahine ka. Session ke hisaab se paise milte the aur mera effective rate ₹300 ke aas paas baithta tha per session. Demo classes ka alag hisaab tha, kuch unpaid bhi thi. Ye baat pehle kisi ne clearly nahi batayi thi.

---

Platform ka sach: jo achha tha, jo nahi

Achhi baat pehle. Students dhoondhne ki tension zero thi. Log in karo, schedule dekho, padhao, log out. Marketing nahi, fee collection nahi, parents se negotiation nahi. Mahine ke end mein paisa account mein. Ek working person ke liye ye system genuinely comfortable hai.

Par teen cheezein khatakti thi.

Pehli: rate fix tha aur mere haath mein kuch nahi tha. Main 16 saal ka experienced teacher hoon, aur mere bagal wale slot mein ek 2 saal ka fresher almost same kama raha tha. Merit ka reward system dheela tha.

Doosri: schedule unka tha, mera nahi. Ek baar Sunday subah 7 baje ka slot mila. Maine request daali change ki, 11 din lage response aane mein.

Teesri: ratings ka pressure. Ek parent ne 2-star di kyunki unke bachhe ko homework zyada laga. Us ek rating se mere agle mahine ke slots kam ho gaye. Matlab mera income ek aise cheez pe depend karta tha jo mere control mein thi hi nahi.

Phir bhi, 14 mahine wahan tika raha. Average mahina ₹6,500-8,500 ke beech nikalta tha, best mahina ₹11,340. School ke saath manageable tha.

---

Direct students wala shift

Shift planned nahi tha. Ek parent (mere school ke nahi, mere colony ke) ne pucha ki main unke bete ko Chemistry padha sakta hoon kya, Class 10 board ka saal tha. Maine haan bola, ₹1,000 mahina, hafte mein 3 din online.

Us bachhe ka result achha aaya. Waise, actually poora sach ye hai: uske marks 61 se 78 gaye, koi 95 nahi aaya. Par parent itne khush the ki unhone apne office ke 3 logon ko mera number de diya.

Wahan se cheezein badli. 4 students, phir 7, phir ek group batch banayi 6 bachhon ki, ₹900 per student. Aaj mere paas 17 direct students hain do batches mein. Mahina ₹16,000-18,500 ke beech aata hai, sirf online tutoring se.

Aur haan, hours almost wahi hain jo platform pe the. Hafte ke 8-9 ghante.

---

Ab dono ka seedha comparison

Paise per hour ka hisaab simple hai. Platform pe mera effective rate ₹300-350 per hour tha. Direct mein ₹1,600-1,900 per hour baith raha hai group batch mein. Ye gap chhota nahi hai.

Par direct ka hidden kharcha bhi hai jo koi nahi batata. Fee collection awkward hai. Do parents aise the jinhone 2-2 mahine ki fee nahi di aur phir bachha chhod gaya. Woh ₹3,800 aaj tak nahi aaye. Summer vacations mein batch aadhi khali ho jaati hai. Ek mahina aisa bhi tha jab naya student ek bhi nahi aaya aur do purane chhod gaye.

Platform pe ye sab unka problem tha. Direct mein ye sab mera problem hai.

Isliye jo log mujhse puchte hain ki konsa better hai, main unse ulta puchta hoon: tumhare paas students laane ka koi rasta hai kya? Agar nahi hai, toh platform se shuru karna smart hai. Wahan online padhane ka craft seekh lo, paise bhi aate rahenge. Aur agar tumhare paas already network hai, school ka experience hai, parents ka trust hai, toh direct ka rasta lamba par zyada deta hai.

Main dono karke aaya hoon aur dono ne kuch na kuch diya. Platform ne mujhe online padhana sikhaya. Direct ne us skill ka sahi daam dilaya.

Ek cheez aur, jo shayad sabse important hai. Physics ya Chemistry jaisi subject specialization ho toh direct mein rate aur bhi better milta hai, kyunki Class 11-12 ke parents specialist dhoondhte hain, generalist nahi.

Agla plan ye hai ki Class 11 Chemistry ki ek alag batch shuru karoon. Rate ₹1,800 rakhoonga per student. Dar bhi lag raha hai thoda, kyunki 11th ka syllabus school mein padhaye hue 6 saal ho gaye. Par jab 16 saal ke experience ke baad bhi kuch naya karne mein dar lagta hai na, toh usually wahi cheez karne layak hoti hai.

Dekhte hain. Agar batch chali toh uska bhi hisaab yahin likhoonga, jaise ye wala likha